"Helping businesses operate more effectively online"

24

Jun

2008

Review of Jom comment for Joomla
Written by David Towers   

Jom Comment comment system for JoomlaAs we have mentioned in the past, Jom Comment is our favourite comment plugin for Joomla 1.0.x and Joomla 1.5.

Today we are going to discuss what we consider to be the strengths and weaknesses of the Jom Comment plugin and we will explain why we use it here at Good Web Practices.

Jom Comment is a comment system plugin for Joomla

Jom Comment makes it possible for website visitors and members to add comments to articles in Joomla. Jom Comment can be installed on Joomla 1.0.x and runs natively on Joomla 1.5.

Getting Jom Comment up and running

The installation of Jom Comment is very easy; it's simply a matter of installing the Jom Comment plugin like any other. Once you have installed it, there are lots of settings you can change. Here are 4 screenshots from the Jom Comment general settings control panel:

Jom Comment general settings Jom Comment anti spam Jom Comment extra settings Jom Comment layout settings

Customising the look of Jom Comment

You can make Jom Comment look different to other Joomla websites by selecting one of the 8 themes that Jom Comment comes installed with. If one of the templates doesn't fit exactly what you are looking for, you can edit the template files located in /components/com_jomcomment/templates/. Here at Good Web Practices we use the Breeze template and after editing comment.tpl.html, index.tpl.html, comment_style.css and changing some of the image files we got the Jom Comment plugin to look just how we wanted it to!

Updating Jom Comment

When you buy Jom Comment you have access to updates to the plugin from the Azrul for a whole year. To install the update you simply need to uninstall the previous version of Jom Comment and install the new plugin. We have tried this out and it works without any problems - just make sure you backup your customised templates because the templates get deleted in the upgrade.

Jom Comment and page load time

One of the downsides of Jom Comment is that it adds a few seconds to page load times. The image below (taken from the Octagate SiteTimer) shows that the Jom Comment CSS, Javascript and images adds about 2 to 3 seconds to page load times here at Good Web Practices. Click on the image below to see the details:

Jom Comment page load time

Strengths of this plugin

  • Very easy to get the plugin up and running.
  • Ajax-based so comments are added on the fly without reloading the whole page.
  • Email alerts when a new comment is added.
  • Support for importing comments from other comment extensions.
  • Integrates with Community Builder and Fireboard.
  • Great anti spam control.
  • Can take control of the "Read more" button and add a "Comments" button.
  • Upgrading the Jom Comment plugin when new versions are released is very easy.
  • Choice of numerous themes helps Jom Comment fit in with your site's template.
  • With some CSS and HTML editing knowledge, you can customise the look and feel of your Jom Comment extension.
  • Documentation accompanying the plugin is thorough.
  • Support from Azrul for Jom Comment is excellent.

Drawbacks of this plugin

  • Jom Comment costs $30 (some see this low price as a strength - see comments below).
  • Jom Comment CSS, JavaScript and images increase page load times notably.
  • When 3rd party component integration is enabled, the Jom Comment CSS and JS is added to every page on the website even pages where Jom Comment doesn't appear - this increases page load time.
  • Not all the HTML output produced by Jom Comment meets w3c standards.
  • When users post comments quoting HTML code, the code just disappears - this can be really frustrating on technical articles: see this for an example.
  • We weren't convinced by usability of the trackback function.

Conclusion

Although Jom Comment will set you back $30 and might add a couple seconds on to page load times, we use it here at Good Web Practices and it is our favourite comment system for Joomla. It is fair to say that the strengths of this plugin heavily outweigh the drawbacks.

We recommend Jom Comment to people looking for an attractive comment system with all the functions you'll need. It's worth noting that we're not alone in recommending Jom Comment, this page shows the extent to which Jom Comment owners are happy!

It's fair to say that Azrul have done a fantastic job with this plugin, and with the 30 days money back guarantee, it's certainly worth trying Jom Comment out!

Buy Jom Comment now from Azrul for $30

What do you think of Jom Comment? Have you used it on your Joomla website?

Comments (41)Add Comment
David Towers
David T
June 25, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +17
...

Glad you have found this useful Jason! smilies/smiley.gif

Is the URL you are adding Jom Comment to: www.jkboyette.com ?

Jason Boyette
Jason Boyette
June 25, 2008
68.252.8.140
Votes: +2
...

Yes, it is www.jkboyette.com , my personal site. I am also interested in adding it to my church's site.

David Towers
David T
June 25, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +1
...

Cool, well if you have any questions about the plugin and its customisation etc feel free to ask!

0
m0nb0f
June 27, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: +2
...

Hi David,
Great, thanks.
Just one thing I saw on your screen-shot :
I use SMF Forum and I saw that we use the avatar forum with Jom Comment ? Without bridge ?! Is it possible ?!
Regards

David Towers
David T
June 28, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +1
...

Hi m0nb0f, I haven't actually tried using the SMF Forum Profile avatar... The Azrul support team will be able to answer your question, I'll see what they have to say.

0
damo
June 28, 2008
213.199.77.130
Votes: +0
...

you say one of the drawbacks is that it costs $30

why do you consider that a drawback?

David Towers
David T
June 28, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +2
...

In my opinion it's a drawback to have to pay for the plugin compared to some alternative comment systems for Joomla which are free. I'm not saying I don't understand why users have to pay for it by the way!

0
damo
June 28, 2008
213.199.77.130
Votes: -1
...

So, what you're actually saying is, it's a drawback because you've got to pay for it.

Based on what you've written above about the component, I'm very surprised you've not put it as one of the strengths; and it only costs $30!

It certainly isn't a drawback and this growing mentality that paying for anything remotely connected to Joomla is a drawback of using the CMS is just not right.

Was it a drawback because you had to buy the template for this site too?

David Towers
David T
June 28, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +1
...

Thanks for your input on this. You're right, the price of $30 could be seen as a strength to this plugin because $30 is certainly affordable and a low price for the quality of the plugin.

Nevertheless, there are other comment systems which exist and are free, e.g. http://extensions.joomla.org/c...temid,35/. So I still think some users considering Jom Comment will see this as a disadvantage.

But yeah I really understand what your saying and have added a note about this in the article.

0
m0nb0f
June 28, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: +1
...

I'm totaly agree with David T.

"Nevertheless, there are other comment systems which exist and are free, e.g. http://extensions.joomla.org/c...Itemid,35/. So I still think some users considering Jom Comment will see this as a disadvantage."

There is http://extensions.joomla.org/c...Itemid,35/ but it's no more supported, for the moment smilies/sad.gif

0
m0nb0f
June 28, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: -1
...

Hey, there is a new support for JoomlaComment http://www.compojoom.com/index.php smilies/grin.gif
David T, could you tell me if, with Jom Comment, there is the same problem with the response of comments : as you can see http://www.compojoom.com/index.php/demo.html, it can outflank over the template smilies/sad.gif Jom Comment is it more clean ?
Thanks
Regards

0
Kyle Ledbetter
June 29, 2008
70.124.82.147
Votes: +2
...

I'm in both camps here smilies/smiley.gif We use JomComment for joomlapraise.com, bc we never really liked the look of !JoomlaComment. However we were able to make it very attractive in our latest template (shameless plug) http://social.joomlapraise.com...&Itemid=74
I think with better styling, !JoomlaComment is more of a contender w/JomComment
@m0nb0f,
Great to see there is new support for !JoomlaComment

David Towers
David T
June 29, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +2
...

@m0nb0f! Thanks for input regarding JoomlaComment.

Jom Comment is clean in terms of messing up templates. In actual fact, the only time I've seen it mess up a template was with a trackback URL. It's worth noting however that this was a problem with the template rather than Jom Comment.

I would encourage you to give Jom Comment a try m0nb0f because the admin backend is great.

@Kyle, I checked out http://social.joomlapraise.com...&Itemid=74 and noticed that you the comment system you had setup looked good. You've done some great customisation there - good work! By the way, I really really like the way you have created custom CSS styles for Community Builder, JoomlaComment, Jcal Pro, Frontpage Slideshow, Fireboard and RSGallery 2 to go with your templates. It's a great way to really add value for people buying the templates. Keep up the good work!

David Towers
David T
June 30, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +3
...

@m0nb0f I just wanted to confirm that Azrul have contacted me to inform us that the SMF Forum avatar can be used without a bridge.

0
m0nb0f
June 30, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: -1
...

@David T, great !
But I still wonder how it can operate without bridge since Joomla has its own table of users and SMF his own.
I doubt that it works without Bridge because at some point we must make the link ...
Finally, should I make a test, but why should I provide a trial version of JomComment.

David Towers
David T
June 30, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +1
...

M0nb0f if you want to trial jom comment you need to https://www.plimus.com/jsp/buynow.jsp?contractId=1663274&referrer=davidtowers If you are not happy with the plugin you can claim a refund within 30 days of paying for the plugin.

Here is the official wording:

"30 Day 100% Money Back Guarantee - If you’re not satisfied, for any reason, within 30 days we will refund your money, no questions asked."

0
magareno
June 30, 2008
89.44.53.88
Votes: +0
...

I have a question:
How to hide the posters ip? Like on this site.
Thanks

0
magareno
June 30, 2008
89.44.53.88
Votes: +1
...

I found out, it`s the template smilies/smiley.gifthat must be modified/changed.

David Towers
David T
June 30, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: +1
...

Hi magareno. You need to edit the html template of the jom comment template you are using. You will find the IP entry it in either comment.tpl.html or index.tpl.html.

0
m0nb0f
June 30, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: +0
...

@ David T,
Maybe I will try but not for the moment, I have some personnal problems to solve before smilies/sad.gif

About the question of magareno, I think for a module paid $ 30, this type of setting (hide IP) could be directly configurable via the BackEnd smilies/grin.gif

Regards

0
eGoDaddy
July 04, 2008
72.86.35.134
Votes: +1
...

...lest we forget that forum support sucks. You have to submit a trouble ticket if you expect a reponse whatsoever.

0
kai
July 08, 2008
203.126.109.21
Votes: -1
...

you got it all right, you can speed up your jom-comment while deactivating the Akismet spam detection service.

David Towers
David T
July 08, 2008
87.90.44.16
Votes: -1
...

Thanks for the tip Kai!

0
Makejo D
July 29, 2008
200.88.80.107
Votes: +1
...

The best option for me in Comments is Jcoment!!

Complete and free

0
m0nb0f
September 03, 2008
89.84.212.129
Votes: +1
...

In my point of view, Jcoment is not complete :
- no avatar
- no CB plugin
smilies/sad.gif

0
Laverdi
October 12, 2008
79.132.172.137
Votes: +0
...

Im glad it works on 1.0.x, because I dont have an option to upgrade to 1.5

0
Patrick
December 09, 2008
60.48.94.26
Votes: +0
...

Thanks for the review. I found that you have given a very detailed reviews on Jomcomment. This definitely gives the potential to have better thoughts before buying this component. Thanks again.

0
Jason Sents
January 16, 2009
125.163.245.197
Votes: +2
...

IMHO, this definitely is - not a drawback.That's for sure. $30 is pretty much affordable considering all advantages this plugin have.

Keep it up guys!

0
Lionel
January 21, 2009
60.49.238.125
Votes: +2
...

Great article...

0
DavidNT
July 29, 2009
98.97.236.166
Votes: +1
...

DavidT,
I've been using Jomcomment for a few weeks and really like the ability to change to different templates to have different look. I also like the vote up and vote down options. The only thing I don't like is the lack of knowing the actual vote counts. Jomcomments has a voting result which is a balance of voteups and votedowns. It would be nice if the actual vote counts (up and down) can be displayed. I believe this feature is available with Joomla Comment.

0
Rahul
August 07, 2009
117.195.13.227
Votes: +0
...

The jom comment component does not send an email. The mesage is succesfuly added. I have intergrated it to my blog and the commenting sytem orks except for teh email. Does not show an error but the email is not sent.

0
ieskau
September 01, 2009
81.7.122.158
Votes: +0
...

Hi,

What module is used for this website comments? Looks nice and clean, light and easy to understand and have all the functions needed to me. If anybody knows, please help! Thanks in advance.

0
luis
October 26, 2009
63.174.175.251
Votes: +0
...

Good....

0
Severins
November 27, 2009
198.208.240.251
Votes: -1
...

How did you change Add comment button?

0
download
February 05, 2010
122.173.76.106
Votes: +1
...

yeah joomla really convert complicated work into easy

0
Jugador
March 04, 2010
190.40.228.132
Votes: +1
...

Parece interesante, veremos.

0
Bala
April 24, 2010
122.164.153.222
Votes: +0
...

You can also add video comments to your Jom Comment smilies/smiley.gif
http://extensions.joomla.org/extensions/extension-specific/extensions-specific-non-sorted/12257

0
otavio
May 21, 2010
189.14.238.202
Votes: +0
...

The jom comment component does not send an email. The mesage is succesfuly added. I have intergrated it to my blog and the commenting sytem orks except for teh email. Does not show an error but the email is not sent.

0
atul4
June 08, 2010
122.161.56.2
Votes: +0
...

The above thought is smart and doesn’t require any further addition.
It’s perfect thought from my side.


Personal ISA

0
JT
June 10, 2010
60.242.13.87
Votes: +0
...

Has anyone considered making sprites out of the all those images associated with this plugin? Does it sound possible?
Here is some info on sprites for you
http://css-tricks.com/css-sprites/

You could add this plugin's css to an existing css file.

Using php we load most of our js using a php file so as most of it is loaded as part of one HTTP request.

If you want to go even faster put the js, images and css on a content delivery network.

The default 4.5 second load time isn't great.

0
tu madre
July 21, 2010
190.131.101.81
Votes: +0
...

zorro
ds
fsd
fsd
f

Write comment
 
  smaller | bigger
 

busy